Michael's Dispatches2 Comments
- Published: Monday, 15 December 2008 18:39
Published: 15 December 2008
In Iraq, there were always a few journalists who would see signs for humanitarian projects like this clinic, translated into to English, and would wax cynical, claiming that it was just propaganda to mask the uglier side of the occupation. I've heard people say things like "This is just for the cameras and the journalists who will devour lies.” Of course, if these signs were not translated into English, an equally cynical person might say, “Look, they aren’t even smart enough to translate the signs into English. How do you expect people to know about the good things you're doing?”
Not that it matters what language signs are printed in Afghanistan: most people in Zabul Province cannot read any language. The government estimates that the literacy rate is, more or less, 15%. Not that they have any real way of measuring. It could be lower. And that is why the schools that are being built by foreigners are the most important thing happening in the country. For Afghanistan to have any hope of basic material progress in coming decades, is important to make sure that girls can attend those schools without fear of having acid thrown on their faces by Taliban members. Boys, for that matter, need access to education unlike the fundamentalist brain-washing provided by the Taliban-run madrassas.
As for the clinics, they are just a small start to meeting the nation's vast health care needs. The sad truth is that for the majority of Afghan peasants, the pathetically small amount of medical care that they received over the war years when they languished in the refugee camps of Pakistan -- occasional inoculations, rehydration salts to prevent deaths to children and infants from diarrhea, antibiotics that we Westerners take for granted, a modicum of hygienic assistance with childbirth -- were the first instances of modern medicine available to them. These clinics, which are pretty basic by our standards, represent a huge leap forward across most of this poor, war-torn nation.
At a moment when much of the Islamic world is suspicious of the U.S., publicizing the positive changes that Western nations have provided is essential. The enemy advertises cutting off heads, or attacking innocent civilians in India, or blowing up a train in Spain. They smile when blowing up tourists in Bali, and dance as buildings fall. We smile when babies recover and the children of illiterate shepherds and subsistence farmers learn to read. You have to be willfully blind not to know the difference between the good guys and the bad guys in this place.
This story can also be found covered at Pajamas Media.
You are a guest ( Sign Up ? )
or post as a guest
This commment is unpublished.· 10 years agoHealthcare and education are the most basic building blocks that will help ensure a stable foundation for any country. Too bad the cynics fail to see the importance, but thank you for emphasizing them.
This commment is unpublished.· 10 years agoPerhaps the problem with western journalists is that they cannot conceive NOT having access to a doctor or hospital. In the U.S., doctors are seen for the mundane --colds, sprains, sore throats. With this in mind, Westerners walk by a place like this and get very cynical. After all, they come from a society where everyone gripes over what they have from either a managed care program, or through Medicaid or Medicare. But imagine living somewhere and never having access to a doctor for major things like surgeries, birth defects, cancer, even hernias, gall bladder disease, wound care or infection. So, those signs stating the time in two languages are necessary since they're only open SIX hours a day (not the 24/7 most journalists can find by dropping into their local ER) and you have to take the gamble that someone in the party will read.