Anatomy of Current Thai Protests

27 April 2014

To understand this dispatch in context, please read the previous dispatches:

Are Thai Protestors Violent?

Whistleblowers: A Meta Organization

We begin:

IMG 1867PDRC members after a deadly grenade attack on a PDRC march. The grenade landed near PRDC leader Mr. Suthep Thaugsuban. Security told Mr. Suthep to get in a car to be whisked away, but he refused to leave and continued marching.

A smaller Whistle Blowing ally of PDRC is Kor Por Tor:  KPT is the Student and People Alliance for the Reform of Thailand.  Various groups have both English and Thai names and acronyms.  In English language newspapers, KPT is often called NSPRT.

KPT has separate leadership and methods, but they ally with PDRC.  KPT also allies with aggrieved rice farmers due to their common goals.  KPT is the only pro-reform group willing to wage open battle.

IMG 1880EOD on the scene after deadly grenade attack on PDRC. UDD Red Shirts often brag before and after these attacks.

The UDD Red Shirts threaten violence daily and commit acts of terror and insurrection too frequently to easily track.  If the UDD were Muslims the US government would label them as an organization that supports and commits terrorist acts. They easily surmount that threshold.  KPT does not.

IMGM4405KPT attacking police during the deadly Din Daeng fighting on 26 December 2013.

To my knowledge, KPT does not commit violence that can be characterized as terrorism or insurrection.  KPT embodies a modified “stand your ground” policy.

IMGM4358This might be a certified PAD Yellow Shirt with KPT during the Din Daeng fighting. ASTV is strongly linked with PAD.

To my knowledge, KPT does not plan offensive actions but will fight defensively. Most KPT members are unarmed and peaceful but their protest guards are armed and they will defend themselves and even counterattack.

IMGM4535Army supporting KPT during KPT attack on police, 26 December 2013 at Din Daeng.

I witnessed KPT not only stand their ground but counterattack police at Din Daeng, Bangkok on 26 December 2013.

IMG 4749KPT medics treat a wounded guard. He was not wounded due to combat. He got into a fight with another guard.

KPT did the same on 18 February 2014, but I arrived after the fight finished that day.

When I arrived on 18 February, KPT was still on the Bangkok battlefield after the police retreated with casualties.  In total, five participants died that day with about a hundred wounded.

IMG 0637Dhamma Army leader Pra Phothi Rak: teaches non-violence. His people have been attacked many times.

That morning, police brutally attacked unarmed members of the Santi Asoke Dhamma Army, a peaceful Buddhist protest group.

The police attacked at prayer time, which enraged KPT who saw this as a moral abomination, not to mention that Dhamma is allied with KPT.

Word spread that police had beaten unarmed monks.  KPT, whose camp was near the Dhamma Army camp, responded immediately with deadly force against the police.

KPT are not like Americans who sit back and videotape police brutality – KPT shoot the police.  But missing from all this is KPT terrorism.  I have not learned of any terrorist attacks from KPT.  KPT engages in open combat and claims their deeds without apology, but these have been quid pro quo responses.

Imagine seeing American police brutalize unarmed protestors.  The equivalent response would be a militia arriving and firing on the police, and capturing their armored vehicles and gear as the police disburse.  The formula for peace with KPT is to not attack them.

Again, I have seen no evidence of KPT later bombing police, or engaging in ongoing attacks.  So far, after the smoke clears from a battle, everyone goes about their business.

Due to the open battles a court decreed that police may not attack protestors unless the protestors violently attack first.  This was a wise decision that ended clashes with protesters so far.  The vast majority of political violence that continues in Thailand comes from UDD Red Shirts who, again, often claim and brag about their deeds.  Strangely, after they openly celebrate their violence, if someone calls them violent they become angry.

IMG 0287Real Thai Soldier, out of Thai uniform, standing guard at a KPT gate. KPT often are attacked after dark.

At Din Daeng on 26 December, the Army aided KPT, but did not arm KPT and did not assist them in their fight against the police beyond providing water, medical care and moral support.  To make this clear: the Thai Army openly aided KPT during the heat of battle with the police formation not 200 meters away from Army elements.

As one might imagine, for an American it would be stunning to watch American military personnel stand by and aid protesters who were attacking police directly in front of them.  But this is Thailand, and we are talking about Thai rules.  I stand not in judgment, only as witness.

(To be continued.)

Comments   

 
+1 # RE: Anatomy of Current Thai ProtestsLorenz Gude 2014-04-28 14:39
Thanks for refusing to put what is happening in Thailand into an easy to understand meme. That is apparently all the press is good for and why I pretty much don't believe anything they say. Evidently things have gotten even more difficult and complex since previous flareups, feelings are still strong and there are no easy answers or solutions in sight. Keep up the good work and stay safe.
Reply | Report to administrator
 
 
+2 # The Uniform Rules?Sun Tzu 2014-04-28 17:38
If I am not mistaken that is a US Army desert uniform, down to the boots, that "soldier" is wearing in the last photo?

Jesus I hope some feckless journalist does not see this and start claiming the US is supporting one group militarily over the other!

That, would open a whole new can of worms ;-)

Take care Michael I think you are actually in a more dangerous situation Siam than in Afghanistan ;-(
Reply | Report to administrator
 
 
+1 # RE: The Uniform Rules?simonferrer 2014-04-28 18:52
U.S. military uniforms are popular fashion in Thailand and both surplus and knockoff uniforms are readily available.
Reply | Report to administrator
 
 
+2 # MrPeter Kennedy 2014-04-29 02:16
Shame to see a seasoned war correspondent abandon independent judgement and throw in his lot with the Yellow Shirts, who like it or not do not represent the majority. Both sides in this dispute are equally bad
Reply | Report to administrator
 
 
# RE: MrSean 2014-05-05 14:16
How is Mr. Yon throwing in with the "Yellow Shirts"? While he appears to have more sympathy for the Whistleblowers, the different articles that he's been writing appear to be pretty factual and not overflowing with opinion or one-sided rhetoric. Considering that no one else is publishing stories about protests in any major news venues, I'm curious about your sources of information and how you came to the conclusion that you wrote.
Reply | Report to administrator
 
 
-1 # noneschmuck281 2014-04-29 03:22
From your second photo it would seem that Kim Jong Un is moonlighting as an EOD tech in Thailand.
Reply | Report to administrator
 
 
# For Mr. Peter KennedyPhillip Mckreviss 2014-06-07 15:38
There is no moral equivalency between the PDRC and the UDD. No PDRC elements employ terrorism.

The UDD, on the other hand, wielded terrorism against PDRC targets on an almost nightly basis. Attacks only ceased after the coup.

Amazingly enough, multiple terror cells and weapons caches were rolled up. Red terror cells. Red weapons caches. Attacks ceased.

Claiming that "both sides are equally corrupt" is intellectually and morally weak. It is also not correct. The two "sides," as you persist in labeling them, mare as different as night and day, and both reflect the characters of their leaders.

PDRC engaged in no terrorism.

UDD did, as a matter of routine.

Bottom line.
Reply | Report to administrator
 

Add comment

Due to the large amount of spam, all comments will be moderated before publication. Please be patient if you do not see your comment right away. Registered users who login first will have their comments posted immediately.


Security code
Refresh

Reader support is crucial to this mission. Weekly or monthly recurring ‘subscription’ based support is the best, though all are greatly appreciated.  Recurring and one-time donations are available through PayPal or Authorize.net.

supp

supp

subscribe

You can now help support the next dispatch with bitcoins:

Donate Bitcoins

My BitCoin QR Code

This is for use with BitCoin apps:

189